Reassessing Bivens: The Judicial Reluctance to Extend Constitutional Remedies

Revisiting Bivens in the Modern Context

The Supreme Court’s willingness to entertain new actions under Bivens v. Six Unknown Named Agents of Federal Bureau of Narcotics remains a poignant question in appellate practice. While the Bivens decision represented a landmark moment for holding federal officials accountable for constitutional violations, its legacy is marred by judicial hesitance to expand its application. The doctrine, now over five decades old, has been extended only twice, as seen in Davis v. Passman and Carlson v. Green. Yet, the reluctance to explore new avenues under Bivens has arguably created a judicial bottleneck, limiting recourse for individuals harmed by federal actors.

Illustration: judge man about 50 notes, with judge bench in a courtroom

The Judicial Hesitation to Expand Bivens

The Supreme Court’s decision to hear the case involving Kekai Watanabe and the alleged constitutional violation by Francis Nielsen offers a fresh opportunity to scrutinize the boundaries of Bivens. Despite the significant implications, the Court has largely resisted expanding the doctrine, as evidenced in Egbert v. Boule where it reiterated that extending Bivens is typically a legislative function. This judicial restraint is not merely cautious; it is a reflection of a broader judicial philosophy that emphasizes separation of powers and the primacy of legislative action in creating new causes of action.

Justice Clarence Thomas’s comments in Egbert underscore the Court’s aversion to discovering implied causes of action within the Constitution. This perspective suggests a doctrinal conservatism that prioritizes legislative over judicial remedies. For practitioners, this means navigating a landscape where the availability of a Bivens action is fraught with uncertainty unless circumstances are “most unusual,” leaving many potential claims unaddressed.

The Two-Part Test for Bivens Claims

The Supreme Court’s “demanding two-part test” for Bivens claims further complicates the landscape. This test examines whether the claim arises in a new context and whether there are special factors counseling hesitation. The threshold for what constitutes a “new context” has become increasingly stringent, as highlighted by the district court’s dismissal of Watanabe’s claim in the absence of a direct analogy to Carlson.

For practitioners, understanding this test is crucial. The Ninth Circuit’s reversal in Watanabe’s case, arguing that the facts parallel Carlson in “all meaningful respects,” suggests a potential avenue for arguing Bivens claims. However, the appellate courts’ divided stance on rehearing the case indicates the contentiousness surrounding such claims.

Legislative vs. Judicial Solutions

The debate over extending Bivens remedies speaks to a larger question of institutional competence. Should the judiciary continue to imply remedies for constitutional violations, or should such actions be the exclusive domain of Congress? The Supreme Court’s preference, as reiterated in recent decisions, leans heavily towards legislative solutions.

This judicial philosophy aligns with broader principles of federalism and separation of powers, underscoring the courts’ reluctance to encroach upon legislative prerogatives. For law firms, this suggests a strategic pivot towards legislative advocacy when seeking systemic changes in constitutional remedies, as opposed to relying solely on judicial avenues.

The Role of Technology in Navigating Bivens Claims

As legal technology continues to evolve, tools like COAPP’s Appellate Brief Generator provide practitioners with analytical insights and compliance checks that are essential when crafting complex Bivens arguments. By leveraging such technologies, attorneys can enhance their ability to draw parallels to established precedents like Carlson or navigate the intricate two-part test.

This technological support is invaluable in a legal environment where precision and adherence to precedent are paramount. As the judiciary remains cautious in extending Bivens, the ability to craft compelling, compliant arguments using advanced tools becomes a competitive advantage.

Concrete Implications and Trade-offs

Consider a hypothetical scenario where a law firm is representing a client in a Bivens-like claim. The firm must weigh the potential $500,000 in damages against the costs and risks of pursuing a claim that may not survive the stringent two-part test. The trade-off involves investing significant resources in legislative advocacy and client education, which might detract from immediate litigation efforts. Additionally, the firm risks a reputation hit if the claim is dismissed early, perceived as overreaching by the court.

Skeptics might argue that investing in legislative advocacy is a long-term strategy with uncertain returns, particularly when immediate client needs are pressing. However, by building a coalition of similarly situated firms and clients, the potential for impactful legislative change increases, offering a broader remedy landscape in the future.

A Forward-Looking Approach for Law Firms

For managing partners and law firm administrators, the ongoing judicial reluctance to expand Bivens serves as a cue to reassess litigation strategies involving constitutional claims against federal officials. Monday morning could see a renewed focus on legislative advocacy and client education about the limitations of judicial remedies.

Furthermore, firms may consider strengthening their appellate practice teams with experts in constitutional law and leveraging technology to ensure their arguments are both innovative and compliant. As the Supreme Court’s stance on Bivens remains conservative, a proactive approach in aligning litigation strategies with legislative developments will be essential for future success.

Built for Colorado appellate practice

COAPP drafts every one of the eleven sections a Colorado Court of Appeals opening brief requires, enforces the C.A.R. 28(g) word limit, formats to C.A.R. 32, and verifies each citation against the record you upload before you file.

Explore the Colorado appellate brief generator →

← All Articles